It was a Wednesday in March, the kind of bright, cold morning when New England holds its breath between winter and spring. The trees were bare, the grass was the color of straw, and the house on Second Street was green — a deep, quiet green, the color of old paint and older secrets. Martin and I had come to Fall River, Massachusetts, to stand in front of the most famous house in America that nobody wants to sleep in. Except, of course, that people do. Every night.

The Lizzie Borden House in Fall River Massachusetts seen from across Second Street
The Lizzie Borden House from across Second Street, Fall River, Massachusetts.

The House on Second Street

The house is narrower than you expect, a three-story clapboard house tucked into an ordinary downtown street, a few blocks from the old mills. Andrew Borden bought it in 1872, and his family lived there until the morning of August 4, 1892 — the morning that made the address famous forever.

That morning, Abby Borden was killed upstairs in the guest room. Andrew was killed downstairs, napping on the sofa. The maid, Bridget Sullivan, was in the house. Andrew’s brother-in-law, John Morse, had stayed the night before. And Lizzie, thirty-two years old, was the one the town decided had done it.

Every American schoolchild knows the rhyme: Lizzie Borden took an axe and gave her mother forty whacks. The record is quieter and grimmer than the rhyme. About nineteen blows fell on Abby. Ten or eleven on Andrew. The rhyme got the horror right and the arithmetic wrong, the way legends do.

Lizzie was arrested a week later and tried in New Bedford in June of 1893. On June 20, after about ninety minutes of deliberation, the jury came back with two words: not guilty. No one else was ever charged. The case has never been closed — not really. It has only been argued about, for more than one hundred and thirty years, by people who were not there and cannot let it go.

The green Lizzie Borden House in Fall River Massachusetts with its bed and breakfast sign and wooden hatchet
The Lizzie Borden House, 230 Second Street, Fall River, Massachusetts.
Gable end of the Lizzie Borden House against a blue March sky
Side entrance of the Lizzie Borden House in Fall River

The sign by the front door says it plainly, with a little wooden hatchet hanging underneath: Lizzie Borden bed & breakfast. Beneath that, in smaller letters: Top 10 Haunted Places in America. The house leans into its legend with a straight face and a wink, and honestly, I respect that.

A Museum You Can Sleep In

Since 1996 the house has been a museum and a bed and breakfast, furnished to look the way it did that summer. The ninety-minute tours walk you room by room, through the story and the theories. At night there are ghost tours, and two-hour ghost hunts — down into the basement, where the little barred cellar window still wears its cobwebs like lace.

Barred cellar window of the Lizzie Borden House with cobwebs

The rooms are booked by name: the Andrew and Abby Suite, the Lizzie and Emma Suite, the John Morse Room, Bridget Sullivan’s room. You can sleep in the very room where Abby was found. I stood on the porch and smiled for the camera like any tourist, which felt strange and ordinary at the same time. That is the thing about this house. It is both a crime scene and a bed and breakfast, and it refuses to choose.

Rhonda standing on the porch of the Lizzie Borden House
Long side of the Lizzie Borden House showing its green clapboard and stone foundation

Brave Enough to Stay the Night

I should tell you something about me: I am brave, and I have always been drawn to the paranormal. Some people visit a haunted house and hurry back to the car. I am the one who wants to stay until the lights go out and the house starts talking. Gettysburg taught me that some places hold onto their stories — you can feel it standing on that ground — and ever since, I have wanted to be in the room after dark, listening, instead of reading about it the next morning.

So yes: I would love to stay overnight at the Lizzie Borden House. I want to book one of those rooms — the Lizzie and Emma Suite, I think — and sleep in a house where two people were murdered and a woman was tried for it and set free, and see what the night has to say. The ghost tours run at 7:30, the ghost hunts run till midnight, and the house is full of people who have felt something they could not explain: cold spots, footsteps on the stairs, a woman’s voice in an empty room. I do not go looking to be frightened. I go looking to understand. There is a difference, and it matters to me.

Maybe next time, I will be the one checking in instead of standing on the porch. If I do, you will be the first to hear about it.

The Cathedral on Second Street

A few blocks up the same street, the granite spire of St. Mary’s Cathedral rises a hundred and ninety feet into the sky — Fall River’s oldest church, built of native granite between 1852 and 1856, with a rose window in the main gable. It was getting some work done the morning we were there, scaffolding along one side, which somehow made it feel more alive, not less. A church being repaired is a church still being used.

St. Mary's Cathedral in Fall River Massachusetts, a granite Gothic church with a tall spire and rose window

It was not the Bordens’ church — theirs was Central Congregational, on Rock Street, where Lizzie taught Sunday school until 1893, when she withdrew her membership because the people who had sat beside her for years were shunning her. That part of the story always stops me cold. Acquitted in a courtroom, convicted in a pew.

Oak Grove

An hour later we were at Oak Grove Cemetery, following the painted arrows on the asphalt under the Prospect Street arch to the Borden family plot. This is not our first haunted ground — Gettysburg taught us that some places hold onto their stories — but Oak Grove felt different. Quieter. No reenactors, no crowds. Just bare trees and a cold wind and a whole family under one tall stone.

The granite monument lists them all: Andrew Jackson Borden, his wives Sarah and Abby, the little girl Alice who died at two, and the two sisters, Lizbeth and Emma. But the stones people come for are the flat ones, low in the grass: EMMA and LIZZIE, side by side.

Flat grave markers for Emma and Lizzie Borden side by side in Oak Grove Cemetery
Lizzie Borden's flat grave marker covered in pennies left by visitors, with yellow flowers

Lizzie’s stone was covered in coins — pennies and quarters left by strangers — and someone had left a bouquet of yellow flowers tied with a yellow ribbon. Every August 4th, on the anniversary, the traffic here swells, and the flowers and notes and stones pile up. The rest of the year, it is just the pennies, winking in the grass, one by one.

An old stone monument with an urn in Oak Grove Cemetery, Fall River
A quiet March morning in Fall River Massachusetts with bare trees

Here is the part of the story that stays with me. After the trial, the sisters left Second Street and bought a grand house on the Hill, which Lizzie named Maplecroft, and she began calling herself Lizbeth. In 1905 they quarreled — over a party Lizzie threw for an actress — and Emma moved out, and the sisters never spoke again. And yet: Lizzie died of pneumonia on June 1, 1927, at sixty-six. Emma died nine days later, on June 10. And here they lie, side by side, as if the quarrel never happened.

Lizzie left $30,000 in her will to the Fall River Animal Rescue League. Whatever else she was, she loved animals. I like knowing that.

Rhonda standing at Lizzie Borden's grave in Oak Grove Cemetery

Lizzie’s Fall River: The Other Houses

Fall River is full of Borden history once you start looking for it, and we spent the early afternoon wandering the Highlands, where the mill money built its big houses on the hill. A few minutes from each other, two more houses caught our eye — and both of them have a Borden story of their own.

The first was a gray Victorian with a bay window and a wraparound porch, and the little plaque by its front door stopped me in my tracks. It read: Phoebe Davenport House, c. 1879 — once owned by Lizzie Borden. Lizzie Borden, landlord. After the trial, she did not just buy Maplecroft for herself. She owned other houses in this town. She stayed in Fall River. She lived her whole life among the people who had decided she was guilty, and she bought property on their streets anyway. There is something stubborn and almost defiant about that, and I admire it more than I can say.

The Phoebe Davenport House in Fall River Massachusetts, a gray Victorian house with a bay window
Plaque on the Phoebe Davenport House reading c. 1879, once owned by Lizzie Borden

The second was red — a deep, handsome red, with white gingerbread trim like icing on a cake, at 511 Rock Street. The plaque there read Remington Borden House, c. 1858. This one belonged to a different branch of the family: built for Joseph Remington, an acid manufacturer, and sold in 1864 to Richard B. Borden, the son of Colonel Richard Borden. A Carpenter Gothic cottage, one of the few of its kind in the city, all pointed arches and delicate vergeboards. The Bordens were not one house and one tragedy. They were a whole Fall River family — mill owners, churchgoers, neighbors — and this red house on the hill is part of that bigger story, the one that existed before August 4, 1892, and kept going after it.

The red Remington-Borden House at 511 Rock Street in Fall River Massachusetts, a Carpenter Gothic cottage
Plaque on the Remington-Borden House reading c. 1858

Why This Case Still Matters

People ask me why I care so much about a murder that happened more than a hundred and thirty years ago, and the answer is simple: because we keep getting it wrong, and getting it wrong has a cost.

First, the rhyme. Lizzie Borden took an axe and gave her mother forty whacks. Children still skip rope to it. But Abby Borden was not Lizzie’s mother — she was her stepmother, and a real woman, and she was killed in a guest room in her own house. Andrew Borden was a real man, napping on his own sofa. The rhyme turns two people into a joke, and once a person becomes a joke, it is easy to forget they were ever a person at all. Remembering this case means giving them back their names.

Second, the trial. Lizzie was tried by the newspapers before she was ever tried in a courtroom, and the newspapers never really let her go. A jury said not guilty in ninety minutes, and her town punished her anyway — her church shunned her, her neighbors whispered, and she lived the rest of her life under a sentence no judge ever handed down. That still happens. It happens every time a case becomes a story before it becomes a verdict, and every time we decide we know what happened because we read the headline. Lizzie Borden is a warning about that, dressed up as a ghost story.

Third, the truth never came. Nobody else was ever charged. Nobody ever confessed. The case was never solved — it was only closed, the way an unsolved case is closed, with the file still open in the back of the drawer. We owe the dead more than a shrug. Remembering means admitting we do not know, and refusing to pretend the rhyme is the answer.

And finally — the part that is hardest to say, and the reason I keep coming back to places like this — Lizzie herself. She was not a rhyme and she was not a monster. She was a woman who taught Sunday school, who loved animals enough to leave them thirty thousand dollars, who bought a beautiful house and renamed herself Lizbeth and tried to start over, who quarreled with the only sister she had left and then died nine days apart from her, and was buried beside her anyway. Whatever she did or did not do on one August morning, she lived thirty-five more years after it, and those years matter too. A person is bigger than the worst thing anyone ever said about them. I believe that. I think that is why this case is important to remember — not because it is spooky, but because it is human, all the way down.

That is also why I want to stay the night. Not to chase a ghost. To sit quietly in a house where history happened, and listen to what it still has to say.

What Stays With You

What stays with me is not the axe. It is the flat stone and the pennies. More than one hundred and thirty years later, strangers still stop, still leave a coin, still argue about a woman they never met. The jury said not guilty. History has never quite agreed with itself.

If you go: the house is at 230 Second Street, and the tours run daily — you can even stay the night, and I hope to, one of these days. Details at lizzie-borden.com. The cemetery is Oak Grove, on Prospect Street. Drive under the arch and follow the painted arrows. Bring a penny. Somebody always does.

So tell me — do you think she did it?

— Dr. Rhonda Moffit


Discover more from Mztressofallevil's Meanderings

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Trending